How to Create a Comic Pull List (and Why It’ll Save Your Collection)

Let’s just say I once forgot to pick up my comic pull list for two months. My local comic shop (LCS) auntie still gives me the side-eye. Not even kidding. Every time I walk in, she doesn’t say “hello”, she just tilts her head and mutters something like, “We got your X-Men waiting.” I deserve it. It was my rookie mistake during my early collecting days, when I still thought “pull list” sounded like some gym workout plan.

Anyway, that brings us here.

If you’re just getting into the world of comics, somewhere between flipping through shiny new issues and wondering where all your money went, someone might mention something called a comic pull list.

And no, it’s not a trap. A comic pull list isn’t just convenience, it’s how serious collectors stay organized, avoid missing key issues, and build their collection with confidence.

What Is a Comic Pull List?

A comic pull list is basically a standing request you give your LCS, telling them, “Hey, I want these titles every month. Please keep them aside for me.”

So instead of walking in every Wednesday and hoping there’s a copy of Spider-Man & Wolverine #whatever still on the shelf, your shop already has it reserved for you behind the counter.

It’s not the same as subscribing directly from Marvel or DC. This is a personal arrangement with your LCS. Think of it like booking a seat in advance. Or, you know, reserving a piece of cheesecake so your brother doesn’t eat it first. Same logic.

Why You Need a Comic Pull List

Let me guess, you’re reading multiple titles, you have a favorite character (Wolverine gang, where you at?), and you really hate missing issues. That’s exactly why having a pull list is essential.

Here’s what it gets you:

• Guaranteed copies of your favorite comics – no more sellouts
• First prints reserved – which matters for value and collectability
• Peace of mind – you’re building your collection, not scrambling every week
• Support for your LCS – seriously, they appreciate the stability
• Fewer impulse buys – well… in theory

Let’s face it. If your plan is to actually collect, not just read casually, this is where structure begins. No one becomes a serious collector by sheer accident.

How to Set Up a Comic Pull List at Your Local Comic Shop

Setting up a comic pull list is easier than you think. You don’t need a secret handshake or anything.

Here’s how it usually goes:

1. Visit your LCS in person.
   Trust me, it’s better than calling. You get to talk face-to-face, and some shops even give perks to regulars.
2. Ask about their pull list system.
   Every shop has its method. Some are old-school paper forms, others use systems like League of Comic Geeks or Previews World.
3. Choose your titles.
   For new collectors working with a modest budget (say around $30–$35/month), I’d recommend starting with 5 monthly titles. That keeps things manageable and still leaves room for bags, boards, and the occasional surprise pick.
4. Provide your name and contact.
   Pretty standard stuff. Some shops ask you to commit to a minimum number of titles. It is usually around 3–5.
5. Pick up consistently.
   Most shops expect you to collect your books weekly or monthly. If you vanish for too long (like ahem… me), don’t be surprised if your books go back on the shelves.

Not sure which is the comic shop nearest to you? You can use the Comic Shop Locator to find your nearest LCS anywhere in the U.S. (or at least near Manila, Singapore, and Jakarta). I got a few examples:

Tips Before You Commit

• Be honest about your budget. Don’t start with 10 titles and then panic at checkout. Comics may be $4.99 each, but they add up fast.
• Start with what you love. Pick characters, creators, or story arcs you’re genuinely excited about. Pull lists are flexible; you can update them anytime.
• Respect the shop’s rules. Some LCSs might drop your list if you skip too many pickups.
• Keep a personal list. Whether it’s an app or a notebook, tracking what you’ve pulled helps you avoid duplicates or missed issues.

What About Online Pull List Tools?

There are digital tools that help you track or even build your pull list, like:

• League of Comic Geeks
• Previews World Pullbox

You have to register to use either of the above. If you are using League of Comics Geeks, you can register it yourself. Browse and create your pull list, and you can then print your comic pull list to give to your LCS.

If you are using Previews World Pullbox, you need to get the invite from your LCS first.

These are great for staying organized and seeing what’s coming out next month. But they don’t replace the experience (and accountability) of talking to someone at your LCS. Plus, no app has ever handed me a free variant cover just because we had a good chat about Claremont’s run.

Frequently Asked Questions About Comic Pull Lists

Q: What if I miss a pickup for a week or two?
A: Your LCS will usually hold your books, but try to let them know in advance. Ghosting them is a one-way ticket to “Blacklist-ville.”

Q: Can I add trades or graphic novels to my pull list?
A: Some shops allow this! Especially if you ask nicely and don’t expect the next Berserk Deluxe to be waiting just because you thought about it. **A: Yes, in many cases you can** but it really depends on your local comic shop (LCS). Some shops allow customers to request trade paperbacks (TPBs) or graphic novels as part of their pull list, but it’s not as automatic as pulling single issues.

Unlike floppies (the standard monthly comic issues), trades and graphic novels aren’t always stocked in large quantities or on a predictable schedule. They’re also often more expensive and come out less frequently. So if you want a specific one, like the latest Berserk Deluxe Edition or Saga Vol. 11, you’ll usually need to:

1. Request it in advance. Shops often place orders based on customer interest.
2. Understand it might take time. These items may need to be pre-ordered from distributors.
3. Be clear about which volume you want. Some series have confusing numbering or multiple printings.

Q: Do I get a discount for having a pull list?
A: Maybe. It’s not promised. Many stores offer 5–10% off pull list items. It’s their way of saying “Thanks for the loyalty (and regular cash flow).”

Q: What if I want to cancel (or add) a title?
A: Just tell your shop. Don’t worry, they won’t sob into their stack of unsold issues… probably.

Comic Pull List FAQ: For First-Time Collectors

Q: What is a comic pull list?
A pull list is a standing request you make at your comic shop to reserve specific titles each month. They hold your issues behind the counter until you pick them up.

Q: Are comic pull lists free?
Usually, yes. Some shops may require a minimum number of monthly titles or ask you to pick up regularly to stay in good standing.

Q: Can I create a comic pull list online?
Yes. Use platforms like League of Comic Geeks or Previews World. But you’ll still need to sync with your LCS to actually receive the issues.

Q: Why do collectors use pull lists?
Because sellouts happen. A pull list ensures you don’t miss first prints or key issues. It also builds a collecting habit without weekly guesswork.

I think that probably covers the basics on the pull list. I will add more if there’s any.

This article is part of The Beginner’s Guide to Comic Collecting, a full roadmap for folks like you who are just getting started with comics.

Here’s where we’re headed:

• You just learned how to set up a comic pull list (good job).
• Next, we’ll go deeper into how to protect and handle those precious issues you’ve started to collect.

Because what’s the point of having mint condition Hulk #1 if your cat sits on it?